Home  ›  Legal Maxims  ›  Torts  ›  In aemulationem vicini
Home  ›  Legal Maxims  ›  In aemulationem vicini

In aemulationem vicini

Term
Torts
Literal meaningIn rivalry with a neighbour
Pronunciationin ay-myoo-lah-tee-OH-nem vih-SEE-nye

An act done only to spite or injure a neighbour. A Scottish law phrase, used where a person uses his own land out of malice.

Example

A man digs a well on his land only to cut off the water flowing to his neighbour, with no purpose of his own.

Case laws
  • Bradford Corporation v. Pickles (1895), House of Lords: a landowner who used his land lawfully was not liable even if his motive was to harm the neighbour.
Exceptions / limits

The House of Lords held that a bad motive does not make a lawful act unlawful.

Exam tip

Asked with Bradford v. Pickles and malice.

Memory trick

Spite against the neighbour.

Key takeaway

A lawful use of land is not unlawful merely because of a spiteful motive.

Home Browse Search Saved